Special Edition: The "Open" Secret—Ranking 20 HR Platforms for Senior Living

We often talk about AI and automation as the future, but today we need to talk about the foundation that makes that future possible: Your HR software.

If you are leading an organization facing the "Silver Tsunami" and turnover rates hovering around 80%, you know that your workforce is your most critical asset. But here is the question: Does your HR software play nice with others?

Why "Openness" Matters (And Why You Should Care)

In the old days, an HR system just needed to print paychecks. Today, a Senior Living HR system sits at the center of a "Data Triage".

Think about the life of a single data point—like a new nurse’s employee ID. In a "Closed" system, your team has to manually type that ID into:

1. The HR System (to pay them)

2. The Time Clock (to track them)

3. The Electronic Health Record (so they can chart)

4. The Learning System (so they can train)

If those systems don't talk to each other automatically (via what techies call an API), you risk "ghost employees" (staff you terminated but who still have building access) and, critically, inaccurate PBJ (Payroll-Based Journal) reporting.

An "Open" system automates this. It acts like a universal translator, letting your scheduling software speak directly to your payroll software without human error.

The Rankings: Who Plays Nice?

A recent comprehensive analysis stack-ranked 20 major HR platforms specifically for the Senior Living industry. The results reveal a massive divide between the "Generalist" giants and the "Specialist" niche players.

Here is how the market shakes out:

Tier 1: The "Platform Architects" (Most Open)

• The Leaders: Sage People, Workday, UKG Pro, Ceridian Dayforce.

• The Verdict: These systems are built to be open. They allow you to connect almost any best-of-breed tool (like a specific scheduling app or AI tool) easily. Sage People took the top spot because it is built on Salesforce, making it incredibly flexible. UKG stands out for its ability to "write back" data, meaning your scheduling tool can actually update your payroll system automatically.

Tier 2: The "Open but Expensive" Middle

• The Players: ADP Workforce Now, Paylocity, Paycor.

• The Verdict: These platforms are technically very capable, but they often come with "Commercial Friction." For example, while ADP has a massive marketplace of apps, they often charge revenue shares that can drive up your total cost of ownership. Paylocity gets high marks for transparency, offering a public portal so you can see exactly what you are buying before you sign.

Tier 3 & 4: The Vertical Specialists (The Trade-Off)

• The Players: Viventium, SmartLinx, Empeon.

• The Verdict: This is where many senior living operators get stuck. These tools are built specifically for our industry (handling things like PBJ compliance out of the box), which is great. However, they are often more "closed."

• The Star: Viventium ranked highest among the specialists because it combines healthcare-specific features with modern connections.

• The Warning: Systems like Empeon and SmartLinx provide excellent functionality but may charge explicit fees (sometimes thousands of dollars) just to set up a connection to another system.

Tier 5: The "Walled Gardens" (Least Open)

• The Players: Symplr, SentricHR, OnShift.

• The Verdict: These systems often rely on older file-transfer methods rather than real-time connections. For example, OnShift is ubiquitous in our space, but it relies heavily on a closed network of partners rather than being an open platform for developers.

The Executive Takeaway

You face a strategic choice: Build or Buy?

• The "Buy" Strategy: If you choose a vertical specialist (like Viventium), you get immediate compliance safety, but you might find it harder (or more expensive) to integrate the newest AI tools later.

• The "Build" Strategy: If you choose a horizontal giant (like Sage or Workday), you get a future-proof foundation, but you will have to do more work upfront to configure it for senior living nuances.

Final Thought: As you look at your tech stack for 2026, ask your vendors about their "API Tax." Are they charging you to access your own data? In the age of AI, data liquidity isn't a luxury—it's an operational necessity.

Have a topic you would like us to cover? Or just general suggestions? Please let us know!

[email protected]